Two pale cocktails and oysters at a quiet window-side table, with soft autumn foliage beyond the glass.

The Old J. Christopher's Corner in Five Points Is Getting a Raw Bar. Here's What to Know About Hin

The empty breakfast restaurant at 1650 S. Lumpkin St. has new tenants. The owners of Puma Yu's, Pete Amadhanirundr and Ally Smith, are opening Hin there with co-owner Molly McClintock. Hin will be a café and cocktail bar, and its plans include a raw bar for oysters and fresh seafood. Visit Athens describes it as taking over part of the former J. Christopher's space.

For anyone who has walked past those dark windows since last year, that is the news. The room's history makes it more interesting. More than a decade ago, a regional chain picked this space partly because it sat away from the downtown bar scene. The next tenant is a cocktail bar run by people who learned their trade in Athens bars and kitchens.

A Storefront That Has Changed Hands Several Times

The space is the ground floor of the Stiles Building, and it has turned over more than once. When The Red & Black covered J. Christopher's arrival, it laid out the history this way:

  1. Five Points Deli held the space first.
  2. The Local Jam came next and closed in summer 2012.
  3. The space sat empty for a while after that.
  4. J. Christopher's signed on in 2013 and was renovating the space that fall, with owners hoping to open within two to three months. It was the company's 22nd franchise, and the brand dates back to a first location in Marietta that opened in January 1997.
  5. J. Christopher's closed in 2025. Flagpole included it in its 2025 Athens restaurant news roundup.
  6. Hin is next, in part of that former restaurant.

J. Christopher's served breakfast, brunch and lunch every day. Before it opened, managing partner Barry Lennon told The Red & Black why the company wanted this spot:

"Five Points has good food traffic and is close to UGA's campus. It's also far enough away from the bars downtown that it brings the perfect mix of locals and college students."

That reasoning held up for more than a decade of pancakes. The renovation he described kept the existing structure and walls and added all new equipment, floors and a new kitchen. Hin will be working inside that same building.

The Team Behind Hin Learned the Business in Athens

Hin isn't a franchise. Its owners built their careers in Athens restaurants, and the details are in a Rough Draft Atlanta profile from October.

Amadhanirundr worked at Seabear Oyster Bar, where Rough Draft says he started honing his skills as a chef. Smith tended bar at The National and The Old Pal. For a team now planning a raw bar and a cocktail program, that is directly relevant experience.

In 2016 the two started a pop-up called The Side Hustle with Kenny Nguyen of Pretty Boy and John Grubrek and Maddie Bilderback of Seabear. Rough Draft reports that it ran every two or three weeks at different spots around town. It eventually settled into regular stints at Little Kings Shuffle Club and The Old Pal, and it stopped in 2020. Smith told Rough Draft the group started after watching pop-ups at Old Pal: "This looks easy." She added, "It wasn't easy, but we were all really young."

Puma Yu's came next. Rough Draft reports that it opened at Southern Mill, 355 Oneta St., in summer 2022, with help from a Kickstarter campaign. The menu is Thai food made with ingredients from Georgia and the rest of the South, much of it bought from farmer friends. Two examples are green curry with Chesapeake Bay catfish and shrimp, and confit-then-fried wings in shio Buffalo sauce.

The Puma Yu's bar gives the best preview of how this team works. Rough Draft describes cocktails built on local produce, such as a tequila drink called Lose My Number made with local tomatoes. There is also a nonalcoholic drink, the First Blessing, made with black tea, toasted grains, lemon, mango, coconut and pandan. Smith described the approach to Rough Draft: "A big focus of the bar is trying to use anything in the kitchen to tie in at the bar [without] buying anything extra. It's a very culinary-focused bar."

McClintock brings a Brooklyn connection. Hana Makgeolli calls itself Brooklyn's first craft brewery dedicated to traditional Korean rice wine, and a 2023 article on its site names McClintock as its head bartender.

What Hin Is Planning for 1650 S. Lumpkin

There are two parts to the plan. Visit Athens describes Hin Bar as "an inventive beverage program" paired with "a specialized raw bar featuring fresh seafood and oysters." What Now Atlanta reports that the brand's Instagram calls Cafe Hin a "daytime companion" to the bar.

So one address will carry a café by day and a cocktail and oyster bar after dark. J. Christopher's used the same room for a breakfast-through-lunch service. The 2013 pitch rested on distance from the downtown bars. Now the corner is getting a bar of its own, run by people who learned the craft behind some of Athens' best-known bars.

The owners have a personal tie to the space, too. Rough Draft says Amadhanirundr calls Hin "the third baby" in the family, after Puma Yu's and their young child.

The Rest of the Row Changed in 2025 Too

J. Christopher's wasn't the only business to leave this part of South Lumpkin last year. Here is how the nearby addresses changed:

Address Business What changed
1650 S. Lumpkin St. Former J. Christopher's Closed in 2025; Hin is taking part of the space
1662 S. Lumpkin St. Former Avid Bookshop Five Points Avid moved to Barber Street in spring 2025; Ghost opened in the space
1557 S. Lumpkin St. Boba Mania Opened in 2025 in a house between Shuman Towing and Grindhouse Killer Burgers

Avid's move was a planned expansion. Shelf Awareness reported in February 2025 that owner Janet Geddis wrote to customers about moving to a larger space at 625 Barber St. She said the relocation was necessary for long-term sustainability and pointed to the new spot's parking and neighboring local businesses. The Red & Black reported that the new store opened its doors June 7.

Ghost moved into the bookstore's old storefront. It sells books, cannabis products and self-care gifts, and its owners, Dave Ranney and Robby Bailey, moved the shop to Athens from Clayton, Georgia. The Red & Black's profile of Ghost describes mushroom lamps, crystals, several bookshelves and a corner for tarot readings.

A short walk away, Flagpole reported in April 2025 that Boba Mania had opened at 1557 S. Lumpkin St.

Together, these changes show one pattern. When businesses left this stretch of Lumpkin in 2025, the spaces went to owner-run businesses with a specific point of view. Hin is the largest of them, and its owners came up through Athens' own restaurant and bar scene.

Where Hin Stands Now

Rough Draft Atlanta reported on October 21 that the owners planned to open Hin in December. Four days later, What Now Atlanta reported that the opening appeared likely to come in 2027. Athens Scoop's November 4 edition also covered the plan. You can follow updates on the café's Instagram, @cafehin, and the bar's, @_hinbar.

If you want to try this team's cooking now, Puma Yu's at 355 Oneta St. is open Monday through Thursday from 5 to 9:30 p.m., and Friday and Saturday from noon to 10:30 p.m. Rough Draft notes that reservations are encouraged.

Over the years the Stiles Building has housed a deli, a jam shop, a breakfast chain and now a raw bar, each one adapting the same structure to a new purpose. If you own an older Five Points house and want to know which updates would prepare it for its next owner, Ellen McLemore Real Estate would be glad to walk through it with you. Schedule your free Revival Home consultation.

Work With Ellen

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact Ellen today.

Follow Me on Instagram